In today’s rapidly evolving educational landscape, the rise of artificial intelligence (AI) tools has sparked an intriguing debate: Can you use AI on college applications?
As a startup that prides itself on leveraging data-driven tools to empower students, we recognize the immense potential AI has in education. But with this potential comes a critical need for caution. While tools like ChatGPT can be a helpful resource, their effectiveness is best when paired with the expertise of a seasoned college admissions advisor. This combination ensures not just accuracy, but also the nuanced insight needed to craft a truly compelling application.
So, let’s dive deeper into this hot-button issue and explore whether AI should be a part of your college application process.
ChatGPT and College Essays: Between the Lines
One of the standout benefits of using AI technologies like ChatGPT is their ability to generate ideas and offer useful information for essay writing. For students struggling to get started, this can be a game-changer.
However, the temptation to let AI write an entire college essay is strong. After all, AI can produce coherent, grammatically correct text that could pass as a well-written response. In a time crunch, students might consider relying on ChatGPT to draft a complete essay for them.
But here’s where things get tricky.
Ethics: The Ethical Dilemma of AI-Generated Essays
The use of AI in essay writing brings up significant ethical concerns. Is it considered plagiarism? Could it be seen as a shortcut that undermines the authenticity of your application? In some school districts, ChatGPT has been banned due to worries about its impact on student learning. Furthermore, companies like Turnitin have developed AI detection tools, with Turnitin’s AI writing detection tool boasting a 98% confidence rate. This means that using AI could risk your application being flagged for dishonesty.
Effectiveness: Can AI Essays Really Compete?
While we haven’t tested ChatGPT’s ability to write a complete essay, others have. The consensus among college admissions experts is mixed. Some believe that AI-generated essays could pass as genuine student work and might even be accepted by certain colleges. One expert noted that they’ve seen students admitted with essays of lower quality than what ChatGPT produces.
Originality: The Missing Element in AI-Generated Essays
Despite the technical proficiency of AI, what these essays lack is the authenticity, creativity, and critical thinking that college admissions officers look for. Without a student’s personal touch, these essays fail to stand out, especially at top-tier schools. Admissions officers would much rather hear your story through your authentic voice.
What Do the Experts Say?
The opinions of educators and admissions officers are crucial in this discussion. A Georgia Tech admissions official stated that “ChatGPT could not compete with live writing coaches or savvy parents in providing feedback to high school students on their personal essays.”
Natasha Singer, a technology writer for the New York Times, echoed this sentiment, saying, “High school seniors hoping to stand out may need to do wholesale rewrites of the texts they prompt A.I. chatbots to generate. Or they could just write their own — chatbot-free — admissions essays from scratch.”
The consensus is clear: while AI can be a supportive tool, it should never be in charge of your college application essays.
AI on Applications: What Are the Rules?
As AI technology continues to evolve, so does the uncertainty surrounding its use in college applications. With relatively few U.S. universities offering clear guidelines, the question of whether or not you can use AI tools like ChatGPT remains a gray area. However, some colleges have begun to take a stand. Let’s explore how different institutions are addressing this issue.
No AI, Whatsoever
Some schools have made their stance crystal clear. For example, the University of Michigan Law School has issued guidelines stating that “applicants ought not to use ChatGPT or other artificial intelligence tools as part of their drafting process.” In these cases, using AI could jeopardize your chances of admission, so it’s best to avoid taking the risk.
Responsible, Moderated Use
Other institutions take a more balanced approach. The Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University allows applicants to use AI tools to prepare their application materials, as long as they do so “responsibly” and certify that all submitted information is true. This means AI can be a part of your process, but honesty and transparency are key.
Just Don’t Copy and Paste
Then there’s Georgia Tech, which has adopted a middle-ground policy. The university’s admissions team encourages students to use AI as a collaborative tool to “brainstorm, refine, and edit” their ideas. However, they caution applicants against directly copying and pasting AI-generated content into their applications. The rest is left to your discretion.
For students applying to multiple colleges—each with its own stance on AI—navigating these varied policies can be challenging. The key is to stay informed and ensure that your use of AI aligns with each school’s guidelines.
How Can You Use AI on College Applications?
Despite the restrictions, there are still plenty of ways to leverage AI in your college application process. Here’s how you can use this technology to your advantage without crossing any ethical lines.
College List Builder Assistant
Feeling overwhelmed by the sheer number of colleges to choose from? AI can help. Use AI tools to generate a list of colleges and universities that match your interests and career goals. Since these tools comb through vast amounts of online data, they can help you discover programs you may not have considered before. Whether you’re looking for summer camps, internships, or niche academic programs, AI can broaden your horizons.
College Programs and Campus Researcher
When it’s time to tailor your application to specific schools, AI can assist in gathering detailed information about each institution. Whether you need to know about particular programs, professors you’d like to work with, or unique aspects of a campus, AI tools can help you compile the insights needed to make your application stand out.
Word Count Editor
Struggling to condense your essay into 500 words? AI editing tools can help you trim down your text while keeping the core message intact. This is especially useful for the activities section of the Common Application, where brevity is key. AI can assist you in polishing your responses, ensuring they’re concise and impactful.
The Bottom Line: Should You Use AI in Your College Application?
While AI offers a range of tools that can streamline the college application process, it’s essential to use them wisely. Relying too heavily on AI for critical tasks like essay writing could backfire, both ethically and in terms of the authenticity of your application. Instead, use AI as a supportive tool—one that helps you brainstorm, edit, and research—while keeping the core of your application firmly rooted in your own experiences and voice.
Empower Your Application with Expert Guidance
Navigating the complexities of college applications can be daunting, but you don’t have to go it alone. The college application process is a personal one, that requires not just data-driven tools but individualized one-on-one help from experts. Empowerly offers a comprehensive package of services combining the use of our Empowerly Score® with the personalized help of college counselors, essay editors, and college admission experts to help students thrive.
Ready to take the next step in your academic journey? Schedule a free consultation with Empowerly today and start realizing your potential!
Sophia Minhas
