In a groundbreaking move, California has become one of the first states in the U.S. to ban legacy and donor-based preferences in college admissions, officially. On September 30th, 2024, Governor Gavin Newsom signed a bill into law that prohibits public universities in California from offering preferential treatment to applicants who are children of alumni or major donors. While surprising, this bold action isn’t coming out of left field. The decision is part of a broader movement to promote fairness and equity in college admissions, particularly in light of ongoing debates about educational privilege and access.
So, what does this mean for college hopefuls and the broader admissions landscape? Let’s dive into the details of California’s ban on legacy admissions.
Why the Ban on Legacy Admissions?
Legacy admissions have long been a controversial topic in the world of higher education. Traditionally, this practice allowed students with family ties to a college—such as a parent or grandparent who attended the school—to receive an edge in the admissions process. While some argued that legacy preferences helped build community loyalty and alumni donations, critics have consistently pointed out that the practice disproportionately benefits wealthier (often white) students and reinforces inequities in higher education.
The bill’s original author, Assemblymember Phil Ting, emphasized that eliminating legacy and donor-based preferences would make the admissions process fairer. According to him, admissions should be based on merit and not on familial or financial ties. In an age when diversity, equity, and inclusion are front and center, many see California’s ban as a major step toward leveling the playing field for all students, regardless of their background.
What Does the New Law Include?
The new legislation applies to all public universities in California, including prestigious schools such as the University of California (UC) and California State University (CSU) systems. Specifically, the law bans admissions preferences based on:
- Legacy Status: Children of alumni no longer receive preferential treatment in the admissions process.
- Donor Influence: Applicants whose family members have made significant financial contributions to the university will not gain an admissions advantage.
It will take effect next year on September 1st, 2025. This change will affect both undergraduate and graduate admissions, ensuring that all applicants are evaluated solely on their academic achievements, extracurricular involvement, and personal qualities.
California’s National Influence
Though California is one of the first states to enact this type of law, the impact could extend far beyond its borders. Legacy admissions have already come under fire in several high-profile cases, including lawsuits that challenge their fairness in top institutions like Harvard University. With California joining the charge, other undecided states may follow suit, prompting a nationwide reconsideration of admissions policies that favor the privileged.
It’s also worth mentioning that some elite universities, like MIT and Johns Hopkins, had already moved away from legacy admissions on their own before this law. However, this ban sets a formal precedent, particularly for public universities that are taxpayer-funded and expected to serve all students equitably.
Many California Colleges Already Ahead of the Curve
While the new law banning legacy and donor-based admissions preferences is a significant step forward for California, it’s important to note that many of the state’s colleges and universities were already compliant—or ready to comply with these changes. In fact, the University of California (UC) system, which includes prestigious schools like UCLA and UC Berkeley, had already stopped using legacy preferences in its admissions process years ago.
The UC system, known for its focus on academic merit and diversity, has long prioritized a holistic review of applicants that excludes legacy or financial influence. This commitment to fairness means that, for students applying to UC campuses, the changes brought by the new law won’t feel drastically different. Applicants have already been evaluated based on their academic achievements, extracurricular activities, and personal qualities rather than family ties.
Similarly, many private institutions in California, such as the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), have also been open to moving away from legacy preferences. Caltech, in particular, takes pride in its strict merit-based admissions policies that aim to cultivate a diverse and academically talented student body without considering legacy status.
What It Means for Future Applicants
For prospective students applying to California’s public universities, what will this change bring? Well, given that many California colleges are either already in compliance or have expressed willingness to adapt to the new regulations, students applying to these institutions are unlikely to experience major changes in how their applications are assessed. For most applicants, the focus will remain on their academic performance, personal essays, extracurricular involvement, and other key factors that admissions officers use to determine fit.
What’s more, public universities like those in the California State University (CSU) system are also expected to comply smoothly. These institutions have historically prioritized access and opportunity for a wide range of students and have not relied on legacy or donor preferences to drive admissions decisions alone. This makes the transition to the new law relatively seamless for the majority of California’s higher education landscape.
Action Steps for Students
With legacy preferences no longer influencing decisions at California’s public universities, students should focus on areas that help their applications stand out in other ways. Colleges are looking for applicants who demonstrate intellectual curiosity, a passion for learning, and a clear sense of purpose. This makes your essays, recommendation letters, and extracurricular involvement more crucial than ever. Admissions officers want to see how you’ve contributed to your community, pursued interests outside of the classroom, and shown resilience in the face of challenges. Make sure these elements of your application reflect your strengths and personal story.
If there are changes to the evaluation process, here’s what to expect:
1. A More Merit-Based Process:
With legacy and donor preferences out of the picture, applicants will be judged more holistically on their academic and personal achievements rather than their family’s connections or contributions. This may open doors for first-generation college students and applicants from historically underrepresented backgrounds.
2. More Diverse Applicant Pools:
Without the influence of legacy preferences, California’s public universities could see a wider array of applicants. This might foster more diversity across campuses, as students from all socioeconomic backgrounds will feel they have a fairer shot.
3. New Pressure on Private Universities:
While the law only applies to public universities, it could add pressure on private institutions in California and beyond to rethink their own admissions practices. Many of these schools rely heavily on legacy and donor relations for fundraising, but they may face increased scrutiny if they continue these preferences.
When in Doubt: Cast a Wide Net
Finally, as you consider your college options, it’s also important to broaden your research beyond just California’s public institutions. Many colleges across the country are evaluating their own admissions policies, and it’s helpful to stay informed about these changes. Be sure to look at schools that align with your academic and personal goals, regardless of their stance on legacy admissions. A diverse college list with a mix of public and private schools—both in and out of California—will give you the best chance of finding a school that is the right fit for you.
The Broader Implications for College Admissions
Why is California’s decision worth so much analytical discussion?
The move to ban legacy admissions in California is part of a larger trend toward making the college admissions process more transparent and equitable. It comes on the heels of the Supreme Court’s decision to strike down affirmative action earlier in 2024, further fueling the debate over how colleges can create diverse student bodies without preferential treatment based on race, legacy status, or financial influence.
Ultimately, California’s ban on legacy admissions could be a catalyst for change across the U.S. It signals a shift away from privilege-based admissions toward a system that better reflects merit and equality of opportunity. As you begin or continue your college application journey, it’s important to stay informed about how changing admissions policies might affect your chances. Remember, your application should focus on your strengths, passions, and unique experiences—those are the qualities that will set you apart, regardless of legacy status or other preferences.
Final Thoughts: What’s Next for You?
In light of California’s move to ban legacy admissions and the broader national conversation on equity in education, we may see similar changes across the country. As these shifts occur, it’s important to focus on what remains within your control. Your academic performance, extracurricular activities, and personal growth will continue to be critical factors in the admissions process. Building strong relationships with teachers and mentors, engaging deeply in your passions, and reflecting on your goals will help you create a compelling narrative for your college applications.
If you need guidance navigating this ever-evolving landscape, Empowerly is here to help. Our team of expert counselors can work with you to build a strategic application plan tailored to your goals. Not only that, our network of counselors is constantly researching developments and changes like this news in California. We’re committed to helping every student find their best-fit college—no matter how the admissions process changes. Reach out today to learn how we can support your dreams.
