How to Get Into Your College of Choice

shallow focus photo of person s left hand
Amy Gardner
Amy Gardner

Our collaborative team of content writers and researchers stay up-to-date on the latest news to help you ace your applications. We hope you enjoy the blog.

In an earlier article, we discussed how to organize your college list into safeties, matches and reaches. It’s important to integrate a variety of these as part of your list, and to be clear about your goals. But can you really get into those “reach” colleges? Schools like Harvard and Yale only accept about 6% of applicants. With the volume of college applications increasing, the chances of being selected by your college of choice feel steep.

But you don’t have to give up on your college of choice just yet. With a little advance planning, you can increase the odds that you, in fact, get into your favorite school. 

First of all:

Keep in mind that not all schools are the same, in terms of what they look for during the process. So, thoroughly research what qualities a college wants in their student body, and what parts of the application matter most.

Commonly, students are advised to involve themselves with a variety of sports, clubs, and volunteer activities. Conventional wisdom is that colleges seek students who are well-rounded.

Although this is true of most colleges, those that are highly selective are not necessarily concerned with finding “well-rounded” applicants.

For example, our admissions data shows that at Princeton and Stanford, college admissions counselors consider extracurricular activities to be very important; but those at Harvard do not. Similarly, Harvard, Yale and Princeton do not place much importance on volunteerism, but Dartmouth does.

The choices that you make when building your college list will in large part determine how to direct your efforts when preparing for the college admission process.

Do your homework

Be sure to do some research on the most sought-after qualities of successful applicants to your dream school. Yale wants students who are uniquely passionate. Princeton seeks those who demonstrate a strong voice in their college essay and are willing to challenge themselves by stepping outside their comfort zone. Stanford looks very closely at application essays and letters of recommendation to find candidates who show intellectual vitality and a love of learning.

In fact, for some of these highly selective schools, marketing yourself as a “well-rounded” student may actually work against you. Unlike most other schools which seek applicants that are generally intelligent but won’t rock the boat, selective Ivy League schools are looking for the folks that will change the world. They are looking for the next great researchers, inventors, political leaders, authors, and social activists.

Angular strategy

This leads us to what we call an angular strategy. For some schools who are not so concerned with finding well-rounded students, this approach cracks the code. They want students who have proven to be highly passionate and accomplished in a particular area. That means giving a laser-like focus to the particular skill or subject about which you are most passionate, and becoming a master of that skill or subject. Devote your energy to fostering brilliance in computer science or playing the cello better than anyone else. This may mean hinder your ability to play a sport year-round or volunteer in a soup kitchen. You will need to be 100% on your game in one particular skill set in order to show college admissions officers that you are capable of great accomplishments in this area.

Focus on your college of choice

There are many positive aspects to being well-rounded, and it’s true that many of your safeties and your match schools may value this as an important quality. But if you aspire to one of the top 10 schools in the nation, you may need to sacrifice some of that “well-roundedness” to developing that one shining area of accomplishment that will stand out to them.

As you set out on your college admissions journey, be sure to identify those schools that line up with your goals most ideally. Include a good mix of safeties, matches, challenges, and reaches. But don’t assume that these “reach” schools are actually out of reach. With plenty of research and strategic planning, they can be within your grasp.

Questions? Let us know!